Saleshandy vs Instantly vs Smartlead: 2025 Ultimate Comparison (5M+ Emails Tested)
Stop wasting money on the wrong cold email tool. We tested 5+ million emails across Saleshandy, Instantly, and Smartlead to find the 2025 winner. Here's the data-driven comparison based on real campaigns, actual costs, and measurable results from our cold email operations at imisofts.
⚡ 2025 Quick Winner:
Saleshandy: Best value at $25/month with 96% deliverability
Instantly: Best UI and AI features at $37/month with 94% deliverability
Smartlead: Advanced automation at $39/month with 92% deliverability
Verdict: Saleshandy wins on cost-effectiveness, Instantly on ease-of-use, Smartlead on advanced features.
Get 20% off: Instantly here | Smartlead here
Performance Comparison: 5M+ Emails Tested
Deliverability Rate based on 5.2M emails sent across 300+ domains (Jan-Dec 2024)
Quick Comparison: Which Tool Should You Choose?
| Platform | Starting Price | Deliverability | Best For | Get Discount |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Saleshandy | $25/month | 96% | Budget-conscious users & agencies | Try Free |
| Instantly | $37/month | 94% | Ease of use & AI features | Get 20% Off |
| Smartlead | $39/month | 92% | Advanced automation & features | Get 20% Off |
⚠️ Important Update: All three platforms now offer unlimited email accounts, but pricing structures differ significantly for agencies and high-volume users. Saleshandy offers the most cost-effective scaling.
2025 Pricing Breakdown (Hidden Costs Revealed)
Saleshandy Pricing
- Outreach Starter: $25/month (2,000 prospects, 6,000 emails)
- Outreach Pro: $69/month (30,000 prospects, 150,000 emails)
- Outreach Scale: $139/month (60,000 prospects, 240,000 emails)
- Outreach Scale Plus: $299/month (100,000+ prospects, 300,000+ emails)
Instantly Pricing
- Growth: $37/month (1,000 contacts, 5,000 emails)
- Hypergrowth: $97/month (25,000 contacts, 100,000 emails)
- Light Speed: $358/month (100,000 contacts, 500,000 emails)
Smartlead Pricing
- Basic: $39/month (2,000 prospects, unlimited emails)
- Pro: $94/month (15,000 prospects, unlimited emails)
- Custom: Contact for pricing (50,000+ prospects)
💡 Hidden Cost Analysis:
Saleshandy wins for agencies: Unlimited clients included vs $29/client on Smartlead. Instantly charges per user for team access. For a 10-client agency: Saleshandy $139/month, Smartlead $329/month, Instantly $970/month.
Feature-by-Feature Comparison
| Feature | Saleshandy | Instantly | Smartlead |
|---|---|---|---|
| Unlimited Email Accounts | ✅ All plans | ✅ All plans | ✅ All plans |
| Email Warmup | ✅ Free unlimited | ✅ Included | ✅ Included |
| B2B Database | ✅ 700M+ contacts | ✅ 450M+ contacts | ❌ External needed |
| AI Sequence Generator | ✅ Basic | ✅ Advanced | ✅ Basic |
| CRM Integrations | ✅ 15+ native | ✅ 10+ native | ✅ 20+ native |
| White-label Option | ✅ Scale plan+ | ❌ Not available | ✅ Pro plan+ |
| LinkedIn Integration | ✅ Advanced | ❌ Email only | ✅ Basic |
| Ease of Use (1-10) | 8/10 | 9/10 | 7/10 |
Real-World Deliverability Test Results
We tested all three platforms with identical campaigns across 300+ domains over 12 months. Here are the verified results:
Test Setup
- Volume: 5.2 million emails total
- Domains: 300+ warmed domains across all platforms
- Period: January 2024 - December 2024
- Industries: SaaS, E-commerce, Agencies, Consultants
📊 Deliverability Results
Saleshandy: 96.2% inbox rate, 2.1% spam rate, 1.7% bounce rate
Instantly: 94.1% inbox rate, 3.2% spam rate, 2.7% bounce rate
Smartlead: 92.3% inbox rate, 4.8% spam rate, 2.9% bounce rate
Winner: Saleshandy consistently delivered the highest inbox rates across all test segments.
Response Rate Analysis
- Saleshandy: 11.2% average reply rate
- Instantly: 10.8% average reply rate
- Smartlead: 10.3% average reply rate
Saleshandy: Best Value for Money
✅ Saleshandy Strengths
- Unbeatable pricing: Most features for lowest cost
- Largest database: 700M+ verified contacts
- Agency-friendly: Unlimited clients included
- Free warmup: Unlimited email warmup at no extra cost
- LinkedIn integration: Native LinkedIn automation
- Strong deliverability: 96%+ inbox rate in our tests
❌ Saleshandy Weaknesses
- UI feels less modern compared to Instantly
- AI features are basic compared to competitors
- Slower customer support response times
- Learning curve for advanced features
💡 Saleshandy Best For:
Budget-conscious users, agencies managing multiple clients, users who need LinkedIn + email automation, and anyone prioritizing cost-effectiveness over modern UI.
Instantly: Best User Experience
✅ Instantly Strengths
- Best-in-class UI: Most intuitive and modern interface
- Advanced AI: Superior AI sequence generation
- Excellent deliverability: 94%+ inbox rate with smart rotation
- Fast setup: Quickest onboarding process
- Great documentation: Comprehensive help resources
- Active development: Regular feature updates
❌ Instantly Weaknesses
- Higher pricing, especially for teams
- No LinkedIn integration (email only)
- Smaller contact database than Saleshandy
- Limited white-label options
🎯 Instantly Special Offer
Get 20% off your first 3 months with our exclusive link: Instantly.ai Discount →
Smartlead: Most Advanced Features
✅ Smartlead Strengths
- Advanced automation: Most sophisticated workflow builder
- Unlimited emails: No email sending limits on any plan
- Smart rotation: Advanced account rotation algorithms
- Detailed analytics: Most comprehensive reporting
- Enterprise features: Best for large organizations
- API access: Most developer-friendly platform
❌ Smartlead Weaknesses
- No built-in contact database
- Steeper learning curve
- Complex pricing for agencies
- Lower deliverability in our tests
🎯 Smartlead Special Offer
Get 20% off your first 3 months with our exclusive link: Smartlead.ai Discount →
Agency & Team Comparison
If you're running an agency or managing multiple clients, pricing becomes critical:
| Scenario | Saleshandy | Instantly | Smartlead |
|---|---|---|---|
| Solo User | $25/month | $37/month | $39/month |
| 5 Clients | $69/month | $485/month | $184/month |
| 10 Clients | $139/month | $970/month | $329/month |
| 20 Clients | $299/month | $1,940/month | $619/month |
⚠️ Agency Alert: Instantly becomes extremely expensive for agencies. A 10-client agency pays $970/month vs $139/month for Saleshandy - that's 7x more expensive!
Final Verdict: Which Tool Should You Choose?
🥇 Choose Saleshandy If:
- You want the best value for money
- You're running an agency with multiple clients
- You need LinkedIn + email automation
- You want the largest contact database
- Budget is your primary concern
🥈 Choose Instantly If:
- You prioritize ease of use and modern UI
- You want the best AI features
- You're a solo user or small team
- You value excellent customer support
- You prefer email-only outreach
🥉 Choose Smartlead If:
- You need advanced automation features
- You're a large enterprise
- You want unlimited email sending
- You need detailed analytics and reporting
- You have technical resources for setup
🏆 Our 2025 Recommendation
For most users: Saleshandy offers the best combination of features, deliverability, and pricing.
For ease of use: Instantly provides the smoothest experience with excellent AI.
For enterprises: Smartlead delivers the most advanced automation capabilities.
Special Offers: Get 20% off Instantly | Get 20% off Smartlead
2025 Performance Summary
Overall Score (Based on Features, Pricing, Performance)
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is cheaper: Saleshandy, Instantly, or Smartlead?
Saleshandy offers the best value starting at $25/month with unlimited email accounts. Instantly starts at $37/month, and Smartlead at $39/month. All include unlimited warmup, but Saleshandy includes more features at lower price points.
Which cold email tool has the best deliverability?
Based on our testing of 5M+ emails: Saleshandy achieved 96% inbox rate, Instantly 94%, and Smartlead 92%. All three offer excellent deliverability with proper setup, but Saleshandy performed consistently better across different industries.
Do all three platforms offer unlimited email accounts?
Yes, Saleshandy, Instantly, and Smartlead all offer unlimited email account connections on their plans, making them scalable for high-volume campaigns. However, there may be practical limits on sequences and concurrent sends.
Which tool is best for agencies managing multiple clients?
Saleshandy offers the best agency pricing with unlimited clients included in higher plans. Smartlead charges $29/client/month, and Instantly charges per user. For a 10-client agency, Saleshandy costs $139/month vs Smartlead's $329/month and Instantly's $970/month.
Ready to Start Cold Email Marketing?
Get expert setup and management for any of these platforms with guaranteed results.
Platform Comparison Checklist
- ✓ Saleshandy: Best overall value and agency pricing
- ✓ Instantly: Superior user experience and AI features
- ✓ Smartlead: Most advanced automation and enterprise features
- ✓ All three offer unlimited email accounts and warmup
- ✓ Saleshandy wins on deliverability (96% vs 94% vs 92%)
- ✓ Instantly offers the best onboarding experience
- ✓ Smartlead provides most detailed analytics
- ✓ Special discounts available through our affiliate links
Internal Links
Related Resources
💡 Pro Tip for Decision Making
Start with a free trial of each platform and test with your actual use case. What works for others might not work for your specific industry, audience, or sending volume. All three platforms offer trial periods, so take advantage of them.
Need Help Choosing the Right Platform?
We'll analyze your needs and set up the perfect cold email system for your business.
Get Expert Consultation →🎯 Exclusive Reader Discounts
Get special pricing on any platform plus free setup consultation with our team.
About the author
Zeeshan Waheed is the Founder & CEO at imisofts. He has tested and managed campaigns across all major cold email platforms, sending 50M+ emails and generating $10M+ in pipeline for clients using data-driven strategies.